Menu

Search

  |   Science

Menu

  |   Science

Search

Head Transplant Is Impossible Right Now Despite Recent Claims By Sergio Canavero

Surgery.scotth23/Pixabay

Last week, news started circulating that the head transplant operation spearheaded by controversial Italian professor named Sergio Canavero was a success. Publications quickly picked the story up and spread the word, but the larger medical and scientific community are intent on putting the brakes on it. According to practically every credible science organization, institution, and journal, a head transplant is simply impossible with current medical technology.

The flurry of headlines and tacky puns started when The Telegraph published an interview with Canavero who claimed that a team of doctors was able to successfully perform a head transplant on a corpse. The operation was done in China, with Dr. Xiaoping Ren of Harbin Medical University leading the team.

After more than 18 hours, the operation was apparently a success, with nerves, blood vessels, and the spine of two people being attached. This is a medical breakthrough that the industry could only dream of and for many professionals in the field, it remains a dream.

One of the people who is skeptical of Canavero’s claim, to say the least, is Arthur Caplan. The NYU School of Medicine medical ethics head, Caplan told Futurism that what the controversial figure said is absolutely impossible. Transplanting a face is hard enough as it is, but doing it with an entire human head is borderline science fiction.

“The way he talks about head transplants, it’s like unscrewing a bulb from a socket and putting in a new one,” Caplan said. “But obviously the chemistry where the new brain will be exposed, and the neural inputs, will be very different. Even if you could keep somebody alive – which I doubt, because of immune rejection – but even if you could, I think they’d be insane, because the brain wouldn’t be able to process the new environment. I think that’s a limit on head transplants, generally.”

Caplan’s views mirror that of many other neurologists, neurosurgeons, and practically the entire global medical community. This isn’t to say that a head transplant will never be performed. It just can’t be done right now or in the near future.

  • ET PRO
  • Market Data

Market-moving news and views, 24 hours a day >

December 11 09:00 UTC Released

ITRetail Sales NSA YY

Actual

-2.1 %

Forecast

Previous

3.4 %

December 11 09:00 UTC Released

ITRetail Sales SA MM

Actual

-1 %

Forecast

Previous

0.9 %

December 11 11:30 UTC 114114m

TREndYear CPI Fcst/Cb Svy*

Actual

Forecast

Previous

10.68 %

December 11 15:00 UTC 324324m

USEmployment Trends*

Actual

Forecast

Previous

135.6 tln

December 11 15:00 UTC 324324m

USJOLTS Job Openings*

Actual

Forecast

Previous

6.093 Mln

December 11 21:00 UTC 684684m

KRExport Price Growth YY*

Actual

Forecast

Previous

8 %

December 11 21:00 UTC 684684m

KRImport Price Growth YY*

Actual

Forecast

Previous

6.8 %

December 11 23:50 UTC 854854m

JPCorp Goods Price MM*

Actual

Forecast

Previous

0.3 %

December 11 23:50 UTC 854854m

JPCorp Goods Price YY*

Actual

Forecast

Previous

3.4 %

December 12 00:30 UTC 894894m

AUNAB Business Conditions

Actual

Forecast

Previous

21 Bln TRY

Close

Welcome to EconoTimes

Sign up for daily updates for the most important
stories unfolding in the global economy.