Daniel Penny, a former U.S. Marine, is reportedly considering filing a malicious prosecution lawsuit against Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg. The potential legal action stems from Bragg’s decision to bring charges against Penny for the May 2023 subway chokehold death of Jordan Neely.
According to Fox News, Penny’s legal team is exploring whether Bragg’s office overstepped its bounds in prosecuting him for manslaughter. Penny was captured on video subduing Neely in a New York City subway after the latter reportedly acted aggressively toward other passengers. The incident sparked nationwide debates on self-defense, mental health, and the criminal justice system.
While Penny maintains that his actions were meant to protect passengers, Bragg’s office contends that Neely’s death was preventable. The charges against Penny were filed following an outcry from activists and political leaders, who labeled the incident a racial injustice. Penny, however, insists that the charges were politically motivated and now appears ready to challenge Bragg in court.
Malicious Prosecution Lawsuit: What It Could Mean
Malicious prosecution lawsuits are notoriously difficult to win, requiring plaintiffs to prove that prosecutors acted without probable cause and with malice. However, legal experts suggest that Penny’s case could be unique due to the intense media scrutiny and public pressure surrounding Neely’s death.
Penny’s potential lawsuit may delve into whether Bragg’s office ignored evidence supporting Penny’s claim of self-defense. During the initial investigation, witnesses reported that Neely threatened subway riders before Penny intervened.
“This case could expose critical flaws in the decision-making process of politically charged prosecutions,” said legal analyst Christopher Dale. “However, it will be an uphill battle to prove that DA Bragg’s office acted with malicious intent.”
If Penny proceeds with the lawsuit, it could also prompt broader discussions about prosecutorial accountability, especially in cases that capture national attention.
Public Reactions Ignite Fiery Debate
The possibility of Penny suing Bragg has sparked a firestorm on social media, with opinions sharply divided:
- @JusticeForAll: “Daniel Penny is a hero. This lawsuit is exactly what needs to happen to hold biased prosecutors accountable!”
- @NYCLegalEagle: “Malicious prosecution is tough to prove. Penny’s case is weak, and Bragg acted within his authority.”
- @FreePennyNow: “DA Alvin Bragg is ruining lives to appease activists. It’s time someone stands up to him!”
- @CivilRightsNow: “Neely didn’t deserve to die, and Penny should face justice. This lawsuit is just a distraction!”
- @SubwaySurvivor: “Penny saved lives that day. The real issue is a broken legal system targeting good citizens.”
- @LegalInsights2024: “This case could redefine prosecutorial boundaries. Watching closely to see if Penny can actually succeed.”
High Stakes for Both Sides
Penny’s lawsuit, if filed, would mark a significant escalation in his legal battle and could set a precedent for prosecutorial accountability in high-profile cases. For Bragg, defending against such claims would likely involve demonstrating that his office followed proper legal procedures.
While Penny has yet to formally file the lawsuit, the mere possibility has reignited debates over self-defense laws and prosecutorial discretion. For now, both Penny’s supporters and detractors await the next move in what has become one of the most polarizing legal battles in recent memory.


Supreme Court Signals Doubts Over Trump’s Bid to Fire Fed Governor Lisa Cook
Trump Proposes Two-Year Shutdown of Kennedy Center Amid Ongoing Turmoil
Zelenskiy Awaits U.S. Details as Ukraine Prepares for Possible Peace Talks Next Week
Federal Judge Signals Possible Dismissal of xAI Lawsuit Against OpenAI
Federal Judge Clears Way for Jury Trial in Elon Musk’s Fraud Lawsuit Against OpenAI and Microsoft
Trump Lawsuit Against JPMorgan Signals Rising Tensions Between Wall Street and the White House
Supreme Court Signals Skepticism Toward Hawaii Handgun Carry Law
Minnesota Judge Rejects Bid to Halt Trump Immigration Enforcement in Minneapolis
Elon Musk Seeks $134 Billion in Lawsuit Against OpenAI and Microsoft Over Alleged Wrongful Gains
Panama Supreme Court Voids CK Hutchison Port Concessions, Raising Geopolitical and Trade Concerns
Bolsonaro to Be Moved to Papuda Prison After Supreme Court Order
Jerome Powell Attends Supreme Court Hearing on Trump Effort to Fire Fed Governor, Calling It Historic
Federal Judge Rules Trump Administration Unlawfully Halted EV Charger Funding
U.S.–Venezuela Relations Show Signs of Thaw as Top Envoy Visits Caracas
Peter Mandelson Resigns from Labour Party Amid Renewed Jeffrey Epstein Links
Starmer’s China Visit Highlights Western Balancing Act Amid U.S.-China Rivalry 



