The Iowa Supreme Court ruled that a country club and steakhouse could not recover losses they suffered due to the COVID-19 pandemic through insurance.
The inability of Wakonda Club and Jesse's Embers to properly utilize their properties when the state banned social meetings and in-person dining in 2020 did not trigger coverage under their property insurance policies, according to Iowa's highest court.
Wakonda Club's policy was issued by a unit of Selective Insurance Group Inc, and Jesse's Embers' policy was issued by Farm Bureau Financial Services.
Both businesses sought coverage after Iowa Governor Kim Reynolds issued a proclamation on March 2020 closing all bars and restaurants from dine-in or in-person service. In May 2020, it restarted limited, restricted in-person operations.
Wakonda Club claimed it was entitled to coverage under an all-risk commercial property insurance policy because the governor's proclamation amounted to a "direct physical loss of or damage to property," but Selective refused the claim.
But Justice Dana Oxley, writing for the 7-0 court, agreed Selective was off the hook, saying that Iowa law requires there to be a "physical aspect" to the loss of use of the property to satisfy the requirement of the club's policy.
Governor Reynolds' declaration, according to Oxley, was prompted by efforts to limit the spread of the COVID-19 virus, not because facilities like Wakonda Club were in imminent danger of physical violence that would result in property loss.
The verdicts were the latest in a string of setbacks for businesses around the country, which had filed hundreds of lawsuits demanding billions of dollars in compensation after governments enforced lockdowns and social gathering restrictions to slow the virus's spread.
The majority of such decisions were made by federal courts interpreting state statutes.
The ruling came after the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court determined in a similar case that the damages of three restaurants did not qualify as property losses needing compensation.


American Airlines Plans Return to Venezuela Flights After U.S. Lifts Ban
Novo Nordisk and Eli Lilly Cut Obesity Drug Prices in China, Boosting Access to Wegovy and Mounjaro
IMF Forecasts Global Inflation Decline as Growth Remains Resilient
Federal Judge Clears Way for Jury Trial in Elon Musk’s Fraud Lawsuit Against OpenAI and Microsoft
EU Recovery Fund Faces Bottlenecks Despite Driving Digital and Green Projects
AstraZeneca’s LATIFY Phase III Trial of Ceralasertib Misses Primary Endpoint in Lung Cancer Study
Tesla Launches New Model Y Variant in the US Starting at $41,990
RFK Jr. Overhauls Federal Autism Panel, Sparking Medical Community Backlash
Nvidia’s $100 Billion OpenAI Investment Faces Internal Doubts, Report Says
Federal Judge Signals Possible Dismissal of xAI Lawsuit Against OpenAI
Jensen Huang Urges Taiwan Suppliers to Boost AI Chip Production Amid Surging Demand
Sanofi Gains China Approval for Myqorzo and Redemplo, Strengthening Rare Disease Portfolio
FDA Says No Black Box Warning Planned for COVID-19 Vaccines Despite Safety Debate
Taiwan Urges Stronger Trade Ties With Fellow Democracies, Rejects Economic Dependence on China
Asian Markets Slide as Silver Volatility, Earnings Season, and Central Bank Meetings Rattle Investors
Elon Musk Seeks $134 Billion in Lawsuit Against OpenAI and Microsoft Over Alleged Wrongful Gains
Royalty Pharma Stock Rises After Acquiring Full Evrysdi Royalty Rights from PTC Therapeutics 



