The Iowa Supreme Court ruled that a country club and steakhouse could not recover losses they suffered due to the COVID-19 pandemic through insurance.
The inability of Wakonda Club and Jesse's Embers to properly utilize their properties when the state banned social meetings and in-person dining in 2020 did not trigger coverage under their property insurance policies, according to Iowa's highest court.
Wakonda Club's policy was issued by a unit of Selective Insurance Group Inc, and Jesse's Embers' policy was issued by Farm Bureau Financial Services.
Both businesses sought coverage after Iowa Governor Kim Reynolds issued a proclamation on March 2020 closing all bars and restaurants from dine-in or in-person service. In May 2020, it restarted limited, restricted in-person operations.
Wakonda Club claimed it was entitled to coverage under an all-risk commercial property insurance policy because the governor's proclamation amounted to a "direct physical loss of or damage to property," but Selective refused the claim.
But Justice Dana Oxley, writing for the 7-0 court, agreed Selective was off the hook, saying that Iowa law requires there to be a "physical aspect" to the loss of use of the property to satisfy the requirement of the club's policy.
Governor Reynolds' declaration, according to Oxley, was prompted by efforts to limit the spread of the COVID-19 virus, not because facilities like Wakonda Club were in imminent danger of physical violence that would result in property loss.
The verdicts were the latest in a string of setbacks for businesses around the country, which had filed hundreds of lawsuits demanding billions of dollars in compensation after governments enforced lockdowns and social gathering restrictions to slow the virus's spread.
The majority of such decisions were made by federal courts interpreting state statutes.
The ruling came after the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court determined in a similar case that the damages of three restaurants did not qualify as property losses needing compensation.


U.S. Reveals 2026 Medicare Star Ratings: Aetna, UnitedHealth Lead in Quality Scores
Sanofi’s Efdoralprin Alfa Gains EMA Orphan Status for Rare Lung Disease
China to Add Eli Lilly’s Mounjaro to National Health Insurance in 2025
Trump Backs Review of U.S. Childhood Vaccine Schedule After Hepatitis B Policy Change
U.S. and Rwanda Sign $228 Million Health Partnership to Boost Self-Reliance
SpaceX Begins IPO Preparations as Wall Street Banks Line Up for Advisory Roles
Silver Prices Hit Record High as Safe-Haven Demand Surges Amid U.S. Economic Uncertainty
U.S. Backs Bayer in Supreme Court Battle Over Roundup Cancer Lawsuits
Pfizer Secures $10 Billion Deal for Obesity Drug Developer Metsera, Outbids Novo Nordisk
Nomura Expands Alternative Assets Strategy With Focus on Private Debt Acquisitions
Dollar Struggles as Markets Eye Key Central Bank Decisions and Global Rate Outlooks
Novo Nordisk Appoints Greg Miley to Lead Corporate Affairs Amid U.S. Drug Pricing Pressure
Pfizer Boosts Bid for Metsera Amid Intensifying Rivalry with Novo Nordisk in Obesity Drug Market
Ford Takes $19.5 Billion Charge as EV Strategy Shifts Toward Hybrids
California, 18 States Sue to Block Trump’s $100,000 H-1B Visa Fee
Bolsonaro’s Defense Requests Hospital Transfer and Humanitarian House Arrest 



