As policymakers revisit the accounting for goodwill, a key question is whether an impairment model provides valuable information to investors, or other users of financial statements. To provide more clarity around the issue, Moody's Investors Service analyzed whether goodwill impairments are a leading indicator of heightened credit risk.
In a report that reviewed rating trends between 2006 and 2015, Moody's found that companies' ratings actually start deteriorating more than two years prior to a goodwill impairment, indicating that impairments validate, rather than predict, increasing credit risk.
"A lack of consistency in valuation and subjective assumptions, combined with little to no warning of impairments from limited disclosure, provide challenges to financial statement users," said David Chan, a Vice President, Senior Accounting Analyst at Moody's. "The subjectivity embedded in goodwill impairment accounting in the US limits its effectiveness and timeliness."
Speculative grade companies are generally more credit sensitive to impairment events than investment grade companies, Moody's found. The speculative grade companies demonstrated more overall ratings deterioration, starting earlier, and with a sharper decline at the time of impairment. Conversely, investment grade companies showed more credit deterioration after the impairment event than before, evidence of their higher tolerance to deteriorating credit conditions.
Moody's report also noted that the higher the impairment, the higher the credit risk. Companies that recorded significant goodwill impairments, on average, had lower credit ratings than companies that did not. Moody's also found that the size of the impairment correlates to the level and pace of ratings deterioration.
Moody's also observed that rating outlooks are, on average, negative more than a year prior to the impairment event. This illustrates that negative factors exist well before any impairment signifying a heightened credit risk.


Moody's Upgrades Argentina's Credit Rating Amid Economic Reforms
Indonesia Surprises Markets with Interest Rate Cut Amid Currency Pressure
Dow Hits 50,000 as U.S. Stocks Stage Strong Rebound Amid AI Volatility
Asian Stocks Slip as Tech Rout Deepens, Japan Steadies Ahead of Election
Gold Prices Slide as Rate Cut Prospects Diminish; Copper Gains on China Stimulus Hopes
Dollar Near Two-Week High as Stock Rout, AI Concerns and Global Events Drive Market Volatility
European Stocks Rally on Chinese Growth and Mining Merger Speculation
Trump Signs Executive Order Threatening 25% Tariffs on Countries Trading With Iran
Fed May Resume Rate Hikes: BofA Analysts Outline Key Scenarios
Vietnam’s Trade Surplus With US Jumps as Exports Surge and China Imports Hit Record
US Futures Rise as Investors Eye Earnings, Inflation Data, and Wildfire Impacts
Australian Household Spending Dips in December as RBA Tightens Policy
Moldova Criticizes Russia Amid Transdniestria Energy Crisis
Asian Markets Surge as Japan Election, Fed Rate Cut Bets, and Tech Rally Lift Global Sentiment
Trump’s "Shock and Awe" Agenda: Executive Orders from Day One
RBI Holds Repo Rate at 5.25% as India’s Growth Outlook Strengthens After U.S. Trade Deal 



